Obstructive sleep apnea is a big public health problem characterized by recurrent events of upper airway obstruction during sleep associated with clinical signs and symptoms.1,2 Obstruction may involve awakening under the effect of increased respiratory effort and a reduction (hypopnea) or complete cessation (apnea) of airflow in the presence of respiratory movements.3 Recent epidemiological research showed a high prevalence of undiagnosed OSA in terms of morbidity and significant associations between OSA and serious medical and social problems, such as hypertension, cardiovascular disease, stroke, and automobile crashes, with overall negative effects on the quality of life.4
A National Center on Sleep Disorders study estimated that between 50 and 70 million Americans are affected by a sleep disorder.5 In the Middle East, 3 out of 10 Saudi men and 4 out of 10 Saudi women are at a high risk of developing OSA.6,7 In the United Arab Emeritus (UAE), the prevalence of symptoms of OSA among adult UAE citizens was found to be very high, and highest prevalence observed was between ages 51 and 60 years in both genders.8 It is clear that OSA is a medical problem and primary care physicians play important role in the detection and proper referral of patients with OSA. Dentists can also play a big role in recognizing OSA, involving in OSA diagnosis, making appropriate recommendations and referrals for OSA patients, and treating OSA with OAs.9,10 Moreover, dentists could be the first healthcare providers to notice the signs and symptoms of the disease, such as a long soft palate, macroglossia, or a small mandible.11 Nevertheless, awareness regarding sleep disorders is insufficient among dentists. Thus, a significant number of patients with sleep disorders remain undiagnosed as a result of limited dental sleep medicine education among healthcare providers.2,10 Most previous studies focused primarily on physicians’ knowledge and attitudes toward sleep disorders.12 Some investigations evaluated the nature and extent of sleep medicine provided in medical schools,13-15 but there were fewer studies that focused on the role of the dentists and their knowledge in relation to sleep disorders and their treatment modalities especially in Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Therefore, the aims of this study were to determine knowledge, educational background, opinion, and clinical experience of general practice dentists toward OSA and OAs.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A cross-sectional study through a questionnaire-based survey was conducted among a sample of general practicing dentists both in public and private dental clinics at Qassim Province, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Ethical approval and informed consent for carrying out the present study was obtained from the ethical committee at Dental Research Centre (DRC), College of Dentistry, Qassim University. A list of dentists and specialist in Qassim was then obtained from the list of Saudi Commission for Health Specialties database. A random number generator was then used to select 200 dentists from this database. Those dentists who were unable or unwilling to fill the complete questionnaire were excluded. The purpose of the study was explained to each participant, and consent form were obtained prior to the distribution of the study questionnaire. The questionnaires were distributed and collected back again after being completed. The paper-based questionnaire used in the study was an anonymous self-administered pretested structured questionnaire that was developed and validated by Bian.9 The questionnaire consisted of 21 questions: The first 5 questions comprised items on demographic data: Age, gender, education level, whether they worked in public or private clinics, and years of experience. Some of the questions were designed to assist knowledge and clinical experience of the participants about OSA and OAs, such as “OSA is a potential life-threatening illness”; “For some OSA patients, an oral appliance is an effective treatment”; “Dentists and physicians should cooperate in dealing with OSA”; “Obstructive sleep apnea is a medical problem, but dentists can detect, diagnose, and treat it.” Respondents were asked to use a 4-point Likert-type scale (strongly agree to strongly disagree) to answer the opinion on items. Other items asked participants to recall their previous clinical experiences regarding OSA and OAs using the following questions: “How many times have you consulted with physicians for a suspected OSA patient in your practice?”, “How many times have you been referred OSA patients by physicians?,” and “How many times have you prescribed OAs for OSA patients?” The last three questions evaluated participants’ previous knowledge of OSA and OAs, such as “Did you learn about OSA in your dental school?,” “Did you attend any postgraduate course about OSA?,” and “Would you like to attend OSA course?” Each question offered two response choices: yes or no. Collected data were analyzed using the SPSS, version 19. The questions were given variable names from Q1 to Q21 of the questionnaire. Then the choices in each question got a numeric value relevant to the corresponding answer of each participant.
Descriptive statistics were performed using frequency count and percentages. The χ2 test was performed to determine the difference between the studied groups at the 5% level of significance.
Out of 200 questionnaires distributed, 175 were returned; the response rate was 87.5%. Table 1 shows the sociodemographic and background characteristics of the study sample.
Only 48.6% of our governmental and private dentists were familiar with the term OSA. A statistical significance was found among governmental dentists (37.9%) who were more familiar with OSA signs and symptoms than private (21.1%) dentists (p < 0.016). Both governmental and private dentists agree that OSA is a potential life-threatening illness (92.6%); dentists and physicians should deal with OSA (94.3%), and OSA is a medical problem that can be detected, diagnosed, and treated by dentists with no statistically significant difference regarding their agreement (Table 2).
Majority of our dentists (90.9%) did not learn about OSA and OA when they were in dental schools. Similarly, the majority of governmental dentists (81.8%) and private dentists (79.8%) did not attend any course on management of OSA. However, most of them (95.4%) were interested in attending OSA management courses (Table 3).
|Variables||n = 175 (%)|
|Place of work|
|College of graduation|
|General practitioner||142 (81.1)|
Opinions about OSA showed statistically significant differences between both groups. About 70.6% of private dentists think that for some OSA patients, OAs are an effective treatment, while 53% of governmental dentists believe in that (p < 0.019). Most private dentists (59.6%) discuss the side effects of OA with their patients.
On the contrary, the majority of governmental dentists did not discuss that with their patients (p < 0.009; Table 4).
Clinical experience variable showed that 76.6% of dentists had infrequently seen patients with chronic snoring or possible OSA. Majority of dentists either governmental or private do nothing for their patients with chronic snoring or OSA. Most dentists did not consult physicians for their cases. Prescriptions of OAs were only done by 22.7% of governmental dentists and 19.3% of the private dentist, and a small number of governmental and private dentists (9.1 and 11.9% respectively) treated their patients with these OAs (Table 5).
Several studies have assessed medical students’ knowledge in the field of sleep medicine.14,15 The literature is lacking significant research to assess sleep medicine knowledge and education among dental students or general practice dentists. General practice dentists are more likely to be among the first to contact who detect, refer, or treat potential OSA patients.16 Therefore, this current study was carried out to investigate the knowledge, educational background, opinion, and clinical experiences of general practice dentists in both government and private clinic toward OSA and OAs. The result showed that 48.6% of our governmental and private practicing dentists were familiar with the term OSA, and 59.0% of our governmental (37.9%) and private (21.1%) dentists were familiar with OSA signs and symptoms. This result also showed that governmental practicing dentists were more familiar with OSA signs and symptoms than private practicing dentists (p < 0.016). This could be attributable to the nature of government dentists’ place of work where they are surrounded by many medical specialties. Previous studies also reported similar data for different countries. For example, 75% of US dentists could recognize the definition of OSA but 58% of them did not know possible common signs and symptoms of OSA.9 The lack of knowledge regarding sleep medicine among our general practice dentists in both government and private sector is the result of the limited time assigned for teaching sleep medicine in dental schools, as only 16 (9.1%) out of 175 dentists learned about OSA and OAs in dental school; 159 (90.9%) knew little or nothing about this issue.
Results of this study are consistent with other findings, which showed that dental school education and postgraduate training seem to fall off behind clinical developments in sleep medicine and sleep dentistry. For example, a survey of medical schools in the United States reported that fewer than 2 hours of the medical education curriculum was devoted to sleep and sleep disorders.17-19 A more recent survey on sleep education in the Medical School curriculum in 12 countries in the Asia-Pacific region and North America reported that the overall time allocated to sleep education was less than 2.5 hours.15 The mean number of hours devoted to sleep medicine in the majority of US dental hygiene program curricula was 1.5 hours.20 Similarly, this phenomenon is seen more clearly in the Middle East dental schools, as only nine Middle East dental schools (23%) reported the inclusion of sleep medicine in their undergraduate curriculum compared with 75.5% of the US dental schools, with a total average hours dedicated to teaching sleep medicine in the corresponding dental schools was 1.2 hours.15 This level of education at many dental schools is inadequate to prepare dentists for their potential role in patient education, screening, and management of sleep-related breathing disorders as the early detection and management of patients with sleep disorders depends considerably on the knowledge and awareness of practicing dentist. In addition, 85.1% of our sample reported that they do not refer OSA patients to physicians, which indicates either poor communication in our medical and dental professional communities or the lack of knowledge among physicians about OAs as a more suitable or alternative treatment than medical therapy for some patients. The lack of knowledge among general practicing dentists in our sample helps explain the inability to detect OSA patients in their clinics. In consequence, 20.6% prescribed OA for OSA patients and 10.9% provide patients with OAs. A considerable number of studies have proved the effectiveness of OAs.21-23 Unfortunately, because sleep medicine education in our sample dental schools is highly limited, it is likely that sleep disorders will be underrecognized and that patients with these disorders may be inaccurately diagnosed and may receive inappropriate treatment. It has been demonstrated that doctors who receive training in sleep disorders are more likely to recognize and treat sleep disorders.14 In practice, dentists should consider more attention to two important matters. First, before dentists assume responsibility for an OSA patient, they should prepare themselves with information about sleep medicine and OAs.21 Second, team approach best manages OSA. Cooperation between dentists and physicians provide professional communication and mutual respect, which is critical for managing the health and well-being of patients.24,25
As a result of this research, we highly recommend two measures: First, an introduction and increase of the number of hours of teaching dedicated to sleep medicine in different courses in the curriculum related to sleep disorders; and second, an urgent need for increasing the awareness and training regarding OSA and OAs in dental school.
General practice dentists surveyed possess poor knowledge and low clinical experience regarding OSA and OAs, which reflects the weak level of education in this field of dental sleep medicine.